Pesach in Cancun with Elan Kornblum & Kosher Luxus Pesach in Las Vegas with Majestic Retreats Talia's Steakhouse
Great Kosher Restaurants
Email To Friend
Friend/co-worker's email address
Your name
Your email address
Close this box Submit
Join Email List
Your email address
Submit Close this box
Click to view next picture
Upper Crust 442 Central Avenue (Bet. Spruce St. & Columbia Ave) Cedarhurst, NY 11516

442 Central Avenue
(Bet. Spruce St. & Columbia Ave)
Cedarhurst, NY 11516

(516) 341-7211

Melanzana- eggplant milanese, fire-roasted tomato, mozzarella, fresh basil
Tuscan Bbq- grilled pollo strips, mozzarella, caramelized onion, red pepper, roasted garlic, bbq drizzle
Caprice- fresh mozzarella, plum tomato, fresh basil
Arrabiatta- spicy marinara, mozzarella, hot cherry peppers
Santa Fe- spicy marinara, mozzarella, pepper jack, taco crumble, ricotta, jalapeno peppers 

Funghi- cremini, oyster,portabella, truffle oil
Quatro Formage- ricotta, mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmesan, roasted red peppers, truffle oil
Buffalo Pollo- crispy vegan chicken, mozzarella, bleu cheese béchamel, buffalo drizzle
Peppadew - peppadew, mozzarella, goat cheese, arugula chippolini béchamel
Kalamata- kalamata olives, roast artichokes, fire-roasted tomato feta cheese, balsamic drizzle 
Mozzarella in carozza- batter-dipped french bread, fresh mozzarella, fire-roasted tomato compote
Italian Nachos - crispy pasta chips, fire-roasted tomato, kalamata olives, hot cherry peppers,  ricotta, mozzarella, arrabiata dip
Brushetta with Roasted Artichokes- roasted garlic crostini, plum tomato, marinated artichoke, fresh mozzarella
Ricotta Crispinis- creamy ricotta, roasted garlic, spinach, gorgonzola cream
Breaded Vegetable Trio with Pesto Aioli- portabella mushroom, zucchini, marinated artichoke
Mini Cheese Calzones- ricotta, artichoke, funghi, mozzarella, vodka dipping sauce
Cheese Board- goat cheese, asiago, ricotta served with dried fruit and crostinis
Antipasti- artichokes, roast peppers, calamata, fresh mozzarella, grilled asparagus, peppadew, roast butternut squash, baby greens, balsamic vinaigrette
Cara Mia- italian greens,roast pear, sun-dried cherries, almonds, warm goat cheese croutons, red wine vinaigrette
Mediterranean Salad- romaine, plum tomato, calamata olive, cucumber, red onion, lemon garlic vinaigrette, shaved feta, sun-dried tomato crostini
Sole` Della Vita- arugula, avocado, fire-roasted tomato, red onion, shaved fennel, red wine vinaigrette
Crispy Pasta and Pesto Salad- romaine, baby spinach, fresh basil, cherry peppers, pignoli, fresh mozzarella, crispy pasta, pesto aioli
The Upper Crust Salad- mixed baby greens, romaine, warm portabella, roast pepper trio, balsamic reduction.served on a crisp flat bread
Cheese Tortellini- charred tomato, asparagus, shaved parmesan, cream sauce
Orechiette- broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomato, gorgonzola cheese
Whole Wheat Pasta Primavera- whole wheat linguini, angel hair zuccini,carrot, yellow squash, parsnip, roasted
garlic, olive oil, touch of butter
Spinach and Ricotta Manicotti- ricotta, roasted garlic, fresh spinach
Vegan Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti- breaded vegan cutlet, ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan
Mac n Quatro Formage- mozzarella, cheddar, feta, ricotta, italian bread crumbs, truffle oil
Eggplant Parmesan with Spaghetti- breaded eggplant, ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan 
Sole Franchais- egg batter dip, lemon caper beurre blanc, fingerling potatoes, vegetable medley
Basil Scented Salmon- pesto rub, parmesan, olive oil, fingerling potatoes, vegetable medley
Pescado Milanese- panko bread crumb, old bay fries, pesto aioli
Chili Rubbed Talapia- three chili blend, olive oil, fingerling potatoes, vegetable medley
information about Upper Crust
Vaad Harabanim of 5 Towns / Cholov Yosroel

Sun - Thu: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Fri: 11:00 AM - 2:30 PM
Sat: 1 Hour After Shabbat-12 AM

Cuisine: Dairy
Avg. Check: $18-$25
Attire: Casual / Casual Neat

Succah On Succot: Yes
Nine Days Menu: Yes
Open for Pesach: No



Contact Restaurant
Your name
Your phone number
Your email address
Question or comment
Submit Question or comment 
ABOUT Upper Crust
Upper Crust, a popular Italian restaurant first opened its doors in the Cedarhurst neighborhood in March 2012 and it hasn’t stopped swinging. Nestled between a bank and a stationary store right in the middle of Central Avenue, Upper Crust is a perfect lunch spot upon completion of your errands. The owner decided to open up this upper class pizza store as a change from the regular fast food venues. With a pizza maker from Sicily and the head chef from Verona, a city near Milan, you are guaranteed high quality authentic Italian cuisine.

Their modern decor featuring classy booths to regular seating options with paintings and mirrored walls, will enhance the fine dining experience. Upper Crust's pizza is currently the first and only kosher brick oven style pizza available in Cedarhurst, and they offer many different selections to choose from. The "Melanzana" made with eggplant Milanese, fire-roasted tomato, mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil is suitable for just about anyone, and there's the "Santa Fe" which is made with spicy marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepper jack, taco crumble, ricotta, and jalapeno peppers, an option that will knock your socks off. The ingredients are always fresh, and there's plenty of personal attention for your every order- so you will feel that your pizza has been designed just for you.

While pizza is the main staple at the restaurant, Upper Crust's menu has an array of all fine Italian dishes. Tease your palate with Mac and Cheese Bite, already a favorite appetizer, or some unique salad dishes including a freshly cut "Sole` Della Vita," comprised of arugula leaves, avocado, tomato, red onion, shaved fennel, and drizzled with a red wine vinaigrette. The pasta dishes smell divine, and your diet can't go wrong with Whole Wheat Pasta Primavera, with angel hair zucchini, carrot, yellow squash, parsnip, roasted garlic, olive oil, and a touch of butter. With an affordable dining opportunity, Upper Crust takes fast food to a whole new level.

Check out reviews from our Great Kosher Restaurant Foodies Facebook Group:


Review3/19/17 (Devorah Lehrer) 

[continued above, right]

7/19/16 (Rachel NeuFryman)

Review 7/10/16 (Jenni Shilcrat)

Review 8/6/15 (Stephanie Michele) 

Review 7/3/15 (Chani Sprei)

Review6/24/15 (Chevi Freidman) 

Review6/14/15 (Hilary Goldstein) 

Review5/3/15 (Sherri Esrog)

Review4/26/15 (Steen Feldman)

Review12/14/14 (Shlomo Klein)
Upper Crust
Leah bander- 08/02/12

the service was great i really enjoyed my time at the upper crust i will definently be returning

1 person likes
Upper Crust
Chaya plum- 07/20/12

the manager of this store is like the coolest person i have ever met he is so sweet and professional

31 people likes

Reply #1 submitted by: latissia gold on 04/03/13

i totally agree i went there a couple of weeks ago and i was treated like a princess by the manager and the rest of the staff i will definitely be returning there!!!!

Upper Crust
Chaia Frishman - 04/16/12

Ate here with a friend. They have AMAZING calzones. Hot out of the oven! Go Adam!

27 people likes

Reply #1 submitted by: jgh on 05/02/12

go upper crust

Fusion Toast Bar
Sadie- 08/10/10
Great Article Meyer!!!
23 people likes
Fusion Toast Bar
Chana- 07/29/10
I had a wonderful experience with this restaurant! I held a large dinner there (approx 17 ppl). It was delicious! It was three courses and they just kept coming out with more food. A good variety of Salatim and appetizers. People commented that it was the best chicken entrée they had every had! The portions were generous and the service was great! They were more then accommodating in many ways. The price was well worth it. Everyone came out happy and full! I have also been there during the week for dinner and had a pleasant experience as well. The price can be a little high for a regular dinner, but they do have coupons and discounts. Overall, it's a great and I highly recommend it.
41 people likes
Fusion Toast Bar
Julie- 07/25/10
This was a great dining experience. Also, very well written article!
30 people likes
Fusion Toast Bar
Natalie- 05/30/10
Great, Geat, Great Food, The best place i have ever eaten in.
35 people likes
Fusion Toast Bar
Dalia- 05/06/10
This Restaurant is incredible. They have great food, fast service, and low prices, definitely give it 5 starts.
16 people likes
<1 2