JChef.com - Fresh, kosher, Meal Delivery Service Pesach with Kosherica - Choice of 4 locations Shiloh Winery Talia's Steakhouse
Great Kosher Restaurants
Email To Friend
Friend/co-worker's email address
Your name
Your email address
Close this box Submit
Join Email List
Your email address
Submit Close this box
Click to view next picture
Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn 1376 Coney Island Avenue (Between Avenue J & K) Brooklyn, NY 11230


1376 Coney Island Avenue
(Between Avenue J & K)
Brooklyn, NY 11230

(718) 337-8226 (TACO)

Buffalo Fingers- Tender strips of all white meat chicken batter dipped and cooked to a golden brown served with celery sticks
Wild Wings- Juicy chicken wings seasoned and cooked to a golden brown then spun in your favorite Carlos & Gabby's sauce
Jalapeno Poppers- A classic Mexican treat. Fresh jalapeno peppers stuffed with Tofutti battered in our homemade cornbread coating & cooked to a golden brown

Chimmichurri Steak Platter- Tender strip steak marinated and grilled Argentinian style, served w/ crisp homemade onion rings & sauteed veggies
Boneless BBQ Rib Platter- Juicy boneless beef ribs slow roasted in our tangy BBQ sauce. Served with crispy shoestring fries, sauteed veggies, chopped salad and a side of BBQ sauce
The Los Alamos- We lost the battle at Los Alamos but this tasty roll will win your taste buds over. Seasoned ground steak, red onion, black beans, jalapeno peppers & fire roasted corn

Magic Mushroom Burger- 6 oz. steak burger, on a soft rolled smothered with fresh grilled mushrooms, caramelized onions and jalapeno creamy sauce
Gabby's Favorite- Thin slices of grilled rib eye w/ caramelized onions & mushrooms, shredded lettuce, ripe tomato & Gabby's special steak sauce
Barbecue Shredded Beef Club- Slow cooked brisket, shredded and marinated in our tangy barbeque sauce. Served with sweet caramelized onions on a toasted hoagie
 Zinger Wrap- Tender strips of breaded tangy chicken zingers, crisp romaine, ripe tomato, avocado ranch dressing, in warm tortilla

The Amigo Taco- Seasoned ground steak, fresh lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeno peppers and tangy taco sauce... Delicioso!
Nacho Grande- Tri-color nachos layered with our zesty chillil, mashed pinto beans, jalapeno creamy sauce, pico de gallo, red onions, fire roasted corn and black olives
Five Alarm Chilli Burrito- Warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around Mexican rice, mashed pinto beans, our zesty home made chilli, jalapeno creamy sauce and diced red onions

All of the above served at the Cedarhurst location as well

information about Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn
Kehilah Kashrus

Sun-Thu 11AM - 1AM
Fri 11AM - 4PM
Friday (Winter)
11AM - 2 hrs. before Shabbat
Sat 90 min. after Shabbat - 12AM

Cuisine: Tex-Mex / American
Avg. Check: $13-$18
Attire: Casual

Succah On Succot: Yes
Nine Days Menu: No
Open for Pesach: No


Instagram: Follow Carlos_and_Gabbys on Instagram
Contact Restaurant
Your name
Your phone number
Your email address
Question or comment
Submit Question or comment 
Scan with phone for
directions to restaurant
ABOUT Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn

Opened in March 2009, Carlos and Gabby's of Brooklyn is the part of the most successful and talked-about Kosher restaurants to hit the New York area in years: Carlos & Gabby's of Cedarhurst (or "The Five Towns" if you prefer). Carlos & Gabby's of Brooklyn continues to bring you all of the great food and fun of the original Cedarhurst location. The colorful and fun restaurant, with Southwestern theme, differentiates itself by giving its customers an eating experience unlike any other. 

They offer an exciting mix of authentic Mexican and southwestern dishes together with classic American fare done with a true Carlos & Gabby’s twist. 

In addition to the exceptional and extensive menu, the Brooklyn establishment features an extensive, decorative seating area with colorful murals, plus, a private upstairs party room - perfect for all your special occasions. Enjoy a Glatt Kosher Mexican Fiesta with friends and family for any occasion.

Book them in advance for any celebration of up to 50 guests. They also specialize in off premise catering. Why serve the same food at every party when your friends or coworkers can enjoy the taste of homestyle tacos stuffed with marinated strips of grill steak? Try something different for your next event. No job is too big, or too small. Let Carlos & Gabby's of Brooklyn feed your guests with the finest Glatt Kosher Mexican cuisine this side of the Rio Grande. The restaurant is kid-friendly place with several menu items for children.

[continued above, right]

And because Brooklyn's nightlife tends to be, shall we say, more lively than the suburbanites, they're open much later for that midnight taco run, or your after-Shabbos burrito. House specialties include the Cedarhurst sandwich, Tacos and Burritos, and the Texas wrangler burger. People would be truly surprised how much time, effort and manpower it takes the staff to prepare the food you enjoy. With one bite, you’ll understand better.

Check out reviews from the Great Kosher Restaurant Foodies Facebook group: 

Review 2/9/17 (Beth Posner GInsberg)

Review 12/5/16 ( Helen Schlesinger)

Review 10/30/16 (Jeremy Asher G)

Review 7/6/15

Review 6/21/15


Carlos and Gabbys Review
Joy Rosenthal- 11/09/14

Carlos and Gabbys Review: ‪#‎gkrmhunt‬ ‪#‎rarestakes‬ Carlos and Gabby's is billed as a Mexican style food restaurant but never fear if you have a preference for American style food, they have that aplenty! My company has always gotten a fair deal by using Carlos and Gabby's to cater events for us. They give us a good price and a good quantity of food and they always arrive on time. Their hamburger/steak sandwiches are a unique take on the regular hamburger and the steak is always cooked just right. Their popcorn chicken is not for the light of stomach but for those who love the fried battered food, this is a definite must! If you're in the mood for a little spice on the side definitely give their spicy fries a chance, they take the word spice quite seriously!

0 person likes
Avrumi Weinberger- 10/26/14

For my eleventh birthday my friends and I went to Carlos and Gabby's in Brooklyn, New York. My favorite dish at Carlos and Gabby's is the Shredded Barbecue Beef Burrito. I really like it because it has very good barbecue flavor and is not too spicy. I usually order it every time I go to Carlos and Gabby's. I think that the staff there are very friendly. I also like the idea of the buzzers that buzz whenever your food is ready. My conclusion is that I think that Carlos and Gabby's is a very nice family friendly restaurant. I think everybody should go eat at Carlos and Gabby's for all different occasions.

1 person likes
Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn
Bracha K- 10/26/14

We have been to Carlos and Gabby's a few times over the past couple of years. So many food choices, it is hard to choose what to try. If you like spicy and Mexican, this is the place for you. We have tried several dishes, including nachos and burritos. Last time I had a salad, so there are healthy options there, too. The reason i decided to write a review, though, is because I wanted to make customers aware that their menu's prices are not updated. When we ate out last time, the prices were actually slightly higher than printed. Nonetheless, I would say a good value for the prices.

0 person likes
Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn
Rosalie- 03/28/12

we tried several dishes from carlos & gabby's...all very tasty, very delicious and very authentic.

0 person likes
Carlos & Gabby's Brooklyn
Eddie cohen- 03/25/09
just took an order from here, take-out . it was super especially the chili burrito. great jalapeño creamy sauce.
1 person likes

Reply #1 submitted by: Deena on 04/27/09
So glad you enjoyed!!! Hope you have been back since, thanks for the compliment!!! Next time stay in if you can enjoy the place and get the nashville!