Pesach with Kosherica in Bahamas & Florida Visit the UN Plaza Grill on Manhattan's East Side Talia's Steakhouse
Great Kosher Restaurants
Email To Friend
Friend/co-worker's email address
Your name
Your email address
Close this box Submit
Join Email List
Your email address
Submit Close this box
Click to view next picture
Bay Cafe 2 Neptune Ave (off Emmons and West End Ave.) Brooklyn, NY 11235

2 Neptune Ave
(off Emmons and West End Ave.)
Brooklyn, NY 11235

(347) 554-8811

Beet Apple w/ Tangerine and Pistachi
Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms
Cold Fish Platter- chubs, kipper salmon, sable
Grilled Veggies- grilled pealed toamtoes, grilled jalapenos, zucchini, peppers, eggplant

The Bay Salad- mixed greens, artichokes, cherry tomatoes, capers, olives served with house special dressing
Mediterranean Village Salad- tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, olives, red onion, feta, house special dressing
Arugula Salad- arugula, sundried tomatoes, goat cheese with homemade raspberry vinaigrette dressing
Roasted Eggplant Salad- homemade eggplant with onion, garlic, roasted peppers and olive oil
Avocado Salad- avocado, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, corn and homemade dressing

Split Pea
House Lentil
Cream of Broccoli

Julianne Crepes- mozzarella, mushrooms and arugula
Ocean Avocado Crepes- avocado, sour crem and smoked salmon

Bronzini- whole
Dorado- whole
Sea Bass- whole or filet
Sesame Seared Tuna

Risotto w/ wild mushrooms
Risotto w/ salmon and olives
Ravioli w/ walnut sage and butter
Tagliatelle Pasta w, butter or Pesto Sauce
Spinach Corn Pie- corn, spinach, feta, olive oil
Moussaka- grilled veggies w bechamel sauce

Three Cheese Grilled Cheese- cheddar, mozzarella, and havarti cheese
Grilled Vegetables w/ hummus
Greek Classic- fresh eggplant salad with spicy feta and olive paste

Ocean Wrap- scrambled eggs, nova lox, red onions and capers
Mediterranean Wrap- scrambled eggs, syrian cheese, mozzarella and tomato

Western Omelet- 3 eggs, zucchini, oniond, peppers, toamtoes, and American Cheese
Italian Omelet- 3 eggs, basil, mozzarella, tomatoes, & peppers
Shakshuka- 3 eggs, onions, tomatoes, bell peppers, tomato sauce and parsley

French Toast

information about Bay Cafe
OK Supervision

Sun-Thurs 7:00 AM- 10:30 PM
Friday - 7:00 AM -Two Hours before Shabbat

Cuisine: Mediterranean
Avg. Check: $20
Attire: Casual

Succah On Succot: No
Nine Days Menu: Yes
Open for Pesach: No


Facebook: Like Bay Cafe on Facebook
Instagram: Follow Baycafebk on Instagram
Contact Restaurant
Your name
Your phone number
Your email address
Question or comment
Submit Question or comment 
Make a Reservation
Reservations for in house dining:
Phone number
Number of people
Your Email Address
Date & Time
Date Select Date Time
Special requests or comments
Submit Request Close
In order to ensure a confirmation for your reservation, it is recommended that you make your request at least 12-24 hours prior to your reservation time. The reservation is not confirmed unless you get an email back from the restaurant. If you do not get an email confirmation back within 4 hours of the reservation time, it is recommended that you call the restaurant to confirm. Great Kosher Restaurants Magazine and the restaurant are not responsible for reservations that are not able to be confirmed.
ABOUT Bay Cafe

Bay Café started with a phone call back in November 2018. They had been non-kosher when they opened back in 2012, but owner Larisa Aronov recognized that there is a need in the area for a kosher café. She contacted us, and we were instrumental in the transformation. We all should be proud of helping make it kosher. It was your reaction, comments, encouragement from a post I made in November 2018 asking if you think they should be kosher that gave them the push to turn kosher. After that, we got things in motion. Over those 3 months, I worked with them in getting the OK Supervision on board, helped get them an interest free loan for new businesses and advised them on many fronts. But that was the easy part. Larisa Aronov and her team had a lot of work cut out for them. New vendors, new rules, new hours and but they went in with their eyes wide open and they are learning more every day and soaking up as much information and feedback as they can to make sure they are proud as well of becoming kosher, and reopened as The Bay café in March 2019.

You can come in for breakfast & lunch & dinner, Bay Cafe is focused on Mediterranean style preparation of fish, appetizers, pasta & risotto, soups & salads. At the Cafe you can find an excellent variety of smoked fish, fresh salads and spreads, omelets & Shakshuka, in-house morning baked pastries & bagels, fine variety of breads, fresh squeezed juices and smoothies.

Attention Kingsborough Community College Students and Faculty: Did you know that there is freshly prepared kosher food in the school cafeteria every day from The Bay Cafe just blocks away in Manhattan Beach? You have a variety of salad and sandwiches, like egg salad, tuna fish, garden salad, Cesar Salad. They can also do catering on their college campus, which by the way is beautiful. Inquire with the restaurant.


Located right off the Belt parkway they offer delivery and before or after your meal, take a beautiful walk along the bay which is across the street from the restaurant. Perhaps you can go fish or just order it. Also check them out on Uber Eats.


Check out reviews from our Great Kosher Restaurant Foodies Facebook Group: 

[continued above, right]

Review 3/7/19 (Nonna Chka)

Review 3/18/19 (Elan Kornblum)

Review 8/3/20 (Andrew Newman) 

Review 8/4/20 (Chaim Haberfeld)

Review 8/9/20 (Tsirel Jewel)

Review 9/15/20 (Tatyana Plotkina)

Review 9/30/20 (Jamie Bernstein Maxwell)

Review 10/1/20 (Avigail G.)

Review 10/7/20 (Tina Namdar Livian)

Bay Cafe
Hope- 08/10/20

I love their food! Great milchig restaurant with a wide variety of dishes. I highly recommend the Bay Cafe.

1 person likes
Bay Cafe in Brooklyn -
Meira Mendelson- 08/10/20

We were fortunate to learn about the Bay Cafe in Brooklyn from Great Kosher Restaurants dot com. It opened just a few weeks earlier. The design and atmosphere in the restaurant is very nice. The Owner-Manager Steve was personable, friendly and eager to please. He was fabulous. We tried this restaurant for brunch since they featured various crepes on their menu and it is a favorite of mine and their crepes were outstanding. We looked into the dinner menu and decided to come back for dinner. Steve, the owner had Branzino Fish specially prepared for me and it exceeded any expectations. And the Ravioli that my husband had was great. And you can't beat their reasonable prices. And they have FREE valet parking! In New York, incredible !!! Thank you again for all the service and information that Elan of Great Kosher Restaurants provides. Keep up the great work! Rabbi & Meira Mendelson, Cleveland, Ohio. We were there April 8th 2019

0 person likes